Review: The Banner Saga 2 for Mac

Published On April 24, 2016 | By David Temple | Macintosh, Reviews

First things first, be warned; there are story element spoilers ahead. If you want to avoid them, just know that we give this game an A grade, so go download it now.

If you’re still here and have played the first installment of Banner Saga, you already know a few things. First, you and your troupe are still traveling, looking for a safe place to survive the Drudge incursion. Second, the world is not very accommodating to you and your companions.

The Banner Saga 2

Third, Iver’s missing arm switches sides periodically, but we won’t hold that against him.

If you have not played the first installment of the Banner Saga, the sequel is still a fun game and easy to get into and play for hours at a time.

First Spoiler: When you start the game, you get to select your character/hero. You can be either Rook or his Daughter Alette. In the story, the character you choose plays and the other is announced as being dead. A bummer to be sure, but there it is—no more daddy/daughter quality time. This does provide some drama and motivation for how you play the story out.

As you lead your rag-tag band of survivors across the wilderness, you will need to stop to train fighters (the Dredge may show up at any time), trade, rest, and award promotions and skill points to your fighters.

The game will, at some points, offer you the option to increase the number of clansmen and/or fighters. Balance these carefully as the fighters consume more resources but offer better protection. More clansmen help with the foraging for food bit, but they can’t help repel enemies.

Speaking of fighting, the combat sequences are fairly standard turn-based affairs with a square grid playing field.

The Banner Saga 2

Since the field is square as opposed to hexagonal, you will need to be extra careful with troop placement (with squares, the diagonal is not considered “adjacent” and your melee combatants will be unable to attack an enemy on the diagonal).

Next Spoiler: Some of your new allies come in the form of a new species to the game, the Horseborn (yes, very much like centaurs). Use your new hoofed friends well and deploy carefully in combat and you will find them a welcome addition.

One odd point regarding combat: I am a bit nonplussed at some of the results of the damage per round inflicted by team player. Like most games, if there is a probability of hit/miss when you wield your weapon in the enemy’s direction, the program either calculates the odds or uses some sort of random number generator to determine whether you hit your target. My issue here is the large Varl berserker (who is, very appropriately, wearing a bear skin) has a base damage of a paltry 1 point. If a large male humanoid berserker wielding two battle axes can go toe to toe and only do one point of damage against a stationary human archer (I scored this several times on the normal difficulty level), it seems a bit lopsided, especially when said archer seemed to have no problem tagging the large Varl for three or four points per hit.

The Banner Saga 2

I can appreciate a fair fight and some effort on the part of the player on the normal difficulty setting, but this was a just a wee bit unexpected.

As with the first installment of the Banner Saga, the looks are very much like a graphic novel and well designed. The vignettes for the combat scenes are nice with plenty of bad guys, obstacles, and the always fun disappearing psycho chickens. The traveling scenery goes from bleak winter storm to sweeping vista, all with your banner flying in the breeze.

The Banner Saga 2

When it comes to the character dialog, you get to make some choices and determine how the story plays out. The NPCs will react differently based on your response, but you are always in a river with a reasonably determined destination. You can save multiple game profiles and each profile can offer a couple of save points from which you can start so you can try different combinations of decisions and actions to see where the story goes, so good re-playability score there. Even just going through the game once is worth several days of serious play, so you get good value for money for the game.

Banner Saga 2 is not a non-stop combat fest; it’s more story telling with periods of action. If your thing is fast paced first-person shooters, this may not be your cup of tea. But if you appreciate story-driven tactical combat as much as we do here at Public Access Gaming, then Banner Saga 2 is a great addition to your virtual box of games.

Genre: Turn-based strategy RPG
Developer: Stoic
Publisher: Versus Evil
Minimum Requirements: OS X v10.7.5, 2 GB RAM, 4 GB available hard drive space
Price: $19.99
Availability: Now at Steam
Grade: A

Like this Article? Share it!

About The Author

is a denizen of the subterranean man cave from which he has been reviewing iOS and Mac games, Mac related gear, and other oddments since 2011. David is an aficionado of many things, and a generally odd individual.

  • Stoic’s response to David’s gripe about berserker vs. archer: “The Strength of the Hero minus the Armor of the target equals Damage. So if a Hero with 8 STR attacks an enemy with 7 ARM they will do 1 Damage…always. If the enemies Armor is higher than your Heroes Strength then there is a 10% to miss for each point of difference. IF you hit you will do 1 Strength damage.”